Stanley: More Than a Water Bottle?

Annie Wilson, Patti Williams

Product #:W41362

Supplier:Ivey

Discipline:General Management, Marketing

Setting:United States, 2023

Details:Case (PDF) • 14 pages • 2025-06-05

Subjects:

Geography:

United States North America

Your Price:

$9.71

Purchase this material with a free Educator Account and enjoy more benefits:

Free Educator Copy
Free Teaching Notes
Build your coursepack
Discounted academic price

Throughout the 2020s, the vacuum-insulated Stanley Quencher water bottle was a full-fledged cultural phenomenon and status symbol, especially among moms and teenage girls. Interest in the brand’s water bottles was coaxed along by affiliate marketing, social media, the release of a range of collectible colours and designs, and cultural interest in sustainability and health and wellness. The hashtag #StanleyTumbler accumulated more than 1.4 billion views. The Quencher was named one of the “12 Objects That Defined 2022” by Fast Company, and the New York Times referred to the brand’s cult-like following as “The Sisterhood of the Stanley Tumbler.” Stanley’s earnings reflected the zeitgeist: the company’s annual revenue grew from US$73 million in 2019 to over $750 million in 2023. But could Stanley maintain this momentum and keep fans engaged or was it destined to be a short-lived trend? Other water bottle brands like Nalgene, S’well, and Hydro Flask had experienced their 15 minutes of fame with similar audiences, only to be left to collect dust in the back of the cupboard when the next, cooler drinking vessel came along. Would Stanley suffer the same fate? Or could the company harness its newfound popularity to become a mainstay brand among mainstream consumers?

Learning Objectives

This case is designed for undergraduate and graduate courses in brand management or dynamic strategy, introducing students to the hit marketing paradigm. It could also serve as a resource in consumer behaviour courses, exploring the psychology of popular trends, or in marketing communications and advertising courses to examine how media and affiliate marketing can be tailored to meet a firm’s short- and long-term goals.

The case is designed to foster discussion on the different marketing strategies required for building and managing a brand versus sparking and milking a fad. This case highlights the opportunities, challenges, and trade-offs associated with marketing and branding decisions for engaging in classical branding versus hit branding, and when to draw from either or both paradigms. After working through the case and assignment questions, students will be able to do the following:

Understand the difference between the classical branding and hit marketing paradigms and the different strategies and tactics required for each.
Learn how to think through deciding whether to use affiliate marketing and its advantages and disadvantages.
Recognize the importance of an initial brand or product concept for sparking a fad and the strategic imperatives for milking it.
Learn how to look for clues that a category, brand, or product is better suited for brand building or hit marketing and assess the risks of either path.
Get a sense of how brand and product meanings can change or be protected as a brand attracts new customer segments.
Discover how brands can synthesize the classical branding and hit marketing paradigms to build brands and drive fads simultaneously.